Sunlit New England sitting room with linen seating, a white radiator beneath the window, and a view of a quiet late-autumn garden.

What It Costs to Heat a Cumberland Center Home This Winter

November 19, 2026

"Fuel is a global commodity and reacts very quickly to the markets and unfortunately we've seen a real spike in heating oil prices," Charlie Summers, CEO of the Maine Energy Marketers Association, told Maine Public in mid-September. Two months later the spike is still here. For anyone touring houses in Cumberland Center this season, two listings at the same price can be very different houses to own, depending on what heats them.

The reason is the gap between fuels. The Maine Department of Energy Resources survey for November 9, 2026 prices one million Btu of heat at $42.01 on heating oil and $50.17 on kerosene. Natural gas runs $14.68 to $22.70 for the same amount of heat, and an air-source heat pump runs $28.72 to $31.36. In a town where natural gas reaches some roads and not others, in the county with Maine's highest share of electric heat, those numbers belong in the offer math along with the list price.

The state's own table, read for a house hunt

DOER publishes the comparison each week alongside its fuel survey. The November 9 edition lists these statewide figures in dollars per million Btu:

Heating source Price per unit, Nov. 9, 2026 Dollars per million Btu
Cordwood $355 per cord $16.14
Natural gas $1.468 to $2.270 per therm $14.68 to $22.70
Wood pellets $357 per ton $21.64
Air-source heat pump $0.098 to $0.107 per kWh, efficiency-adjusted $28.72 to $31.36
Propane $3.64 per gallon $39.78
Heating oil $5.84 per gallon $42.01
Kerosene $6.77 per gallon $50.17
Electric baseboard $0.286 to $0.313 per kWh $83.82 to $91.74

Read it with two adjustments. The heat pump and baseboard rows already reflect how efficiently each system turns electricity into heat, with DOER using Efficiency Maine's figure that a heat pump is 2.93 times as efficient as electric resistance heat. The oil, propane and kerosene rows show the fuel alone, so the real cost per unit of heat rises once a furnace or boiler's efficiency is factored in. The natural gas range includes minimum monthly fees, and the electricity figures use CMP and Versant supply and delivery prices as of July 1, 2026.

Even with those adjustments, the ordering holds. A Cumberland Center colonial heated entirely by an oil boiler and a similar house on a gas line with a heat pump for the shoulder seasons are paying very different amounts for each unit of warmth this winter.

Why oil sits where it does

A year ago the picture looked different. On DOER's November 10, 2025 survey, heating oil in the Southeast/Greater Portland region averaged $3.47 a gallon and propane averaged $3.51, nearly even per gallon. On the November 9, 2026 survey, the same region showed oil at $5.83 and propane at $4.02. Over those twelve months, oil rose $2.36 a gallon in Greater Portland and propane rose $0.51.

The Bangor Daily News reported on October 2 that Maine oil prices were about 80 percent above the prior year and tied the increase to the conflicts in Ukraine and Iran and to disruptions around the Strait of Hormuz. Maine Public later cited U.S. attacks on Iran and constrained distillate refining capacity. The statewide average peaked at $6.04 on October 19, eased to $6.01 on November 2 and fell to $5.84 on November 9. That is a small step down from a record, and the price still swings week to week. A buyer budgeting an oil-heated house should treat the per-gallon figure as a moving number for the whole winter.

What Cumberland dealers are posting

The state average is a cash spot price, and individual quotes vary. On the MaineOil Greater Portland price list, several dealers that list Cumberland posted prices below the state's $5.84 in the week of November 9: Higgins Energy at $5.399 on November 10, Maine Standard Biofuels at $5.290 on November 9, and Vic & Sons Fuel Co. at $5.279 on November 14. Sunrise Oil, listed for Portland and Falmouth, posted $5.299 on November 11. Those are posted cash prices, and the list doesn't show delivery terms, minimums or contract options.

For scale, WGME priced a 275-gallon fill at $1,641 in early October, when oil was near $5.97. Summers' group has recommended that households talk with their dealers about automatic delivery and fixed-price options, according to Maine Public. For a buyer, this means the seller's delivery arrangement and the fuel left in the tank at closing are worth asking about early.

Natural gas comes down to the street

Summit Natural Gas of Maine serves Cumberland. Its posted residential rates for the town are $1.3630 per therm for distribution plus a $0.586 per therm commodity adjustment, with a $30.32 monthly charge. The commodity adjustment can move, so check the current tariff before building a budget around it.

Which houses can use gas depends on where the mains went in, and in Cumberland they followed road work. Town Council minutes from July 2013 describe a planned 6,000-foot Summit main from Skillin Road to Bruce Hill Road, coordinated with the Blanchard Road reconstruction. A town report from December 2017 describes gas lines going in with the Middle Road reconstruction, from Tuttle Road toward the Falmouth line. Those records show where mains were planned. They don't show whether a particular house is connected. Summit's service area lookup checks one address at a time and directs residents to contact the company about their street.

So a house on oil with a gas main in the street has a possible way to change fuels, and a house on oil with no main nearby does not. Two otherwise similar listings can differ on exactly that point.

Heat pumps, and a rate with a January date

Cumberland County leads Maine in electric heat. The Bangor Daily News reported in February, using Census data, that more than 14 percent of the county's households heat with electricity, up from under 8 percent before 2020. When a listing has heat pumps alongside a boiler or furnace, the questions are how much of the house those units cover and what the electric bill looks like.

CMP's standard residential price as of July 1, 2026 is 24.68 cents per kWh above the first 50 kWh, combining 11.959 cents of delivery with the 2026 standard-offer supply rate of 12.721 cents, plus a $27.37 monthly charge, according to the Maine Public Utilities Commission. CMP also lists an optional Electric Technology delivery rate of 8.9 cents per kWh with a $41.24 monthly charge, and its pricing page shows that rate set to expire in January 2027. A seller's electric bills will show which rate the account was on.

Adding heat pumps after closing is the other path, and Efficiency Maine lists 2026 whole-home heat pump rebates of up to $9,000 per housing unit. Timing is the catch this year. Bridget Gifford of Efficiency Maine told the Bangor Daily News in October that some heat pump and insulation contractors have growing backlogs, and Matt Wagner of Upright Energy reported more interest in installations. A buyer closing in December who plans to install heat pumps may be heating with the existing system for most of the winter. The rates and rebates here are general information as of their stated dates, not financial or tax advice, so confirm your own figures with the utility, Efficiency Maine and your own advisors.

What to request before writing an offer

All of this comes down to a short list a buyer can bring to a showing in Cumberland Center:

  1. The primary heating fuel and system, its age, and any service records.
  2. Whether the oil or propane tank is owned or leased, its age, and what the seller's delivery arrangement is, including any fixed-price contract.
  3. Twelve months of fuel and electric bills, with the dates and gallons for each delivery.
  4. Whether a Summit main serves the address, checked through Summit's lookup.
  5. The number of heat pump units, which rooms they cover, and which CMP rate the account uses.

Read the bills against the dates. Fuel bills from last winter reflect oil near $3.47 a gallon in Greater Portland, and this winter started near $5.83. DOER's heating fuel prices page links to the state's home heating calculator, which estimates costs by fuel, system and appliance.

Quick answers

Is propane cheaper than oil right now? On the November 9 survey, yes, before system efficiency: $39.78 per million Btu statewide for propane and $42.01 for oil. In Greater Portland, propane averaged $4.02 a gallon, above the statewide $3.64, and households that use propane only for cooking or hot water generally pay more per gallon.

Where does wood fit? Cordwood came in at $16.14 per million Btu and pellets at $21.64 on the same table, with prices based on informal dealer surveys that include delivery. A woodstove or pellet stove in a Cumberland farmhouse is worth asking about at the showing.

If a Cumberland Center house has you weighing an oil boiler against a gas main or a set of heat pumps, bring us the heating questions along with the price. Explore our Cumberland Center neighborhood guide or current Cumberland Center listings, and when a house looks right, let's talk about your next move with Dambrie Garon Real Estate Advisors.

Contact Us

Fill out the form below to learn more about buying or selling a house in your area.

Work With Us

Dambrie Garon Real Estate Advisors offers their clients particular expertise in the buying and selling of single and multi-family properties, new construction, and subdivision projects. Our clients benefit from our insights into home renovations, knowing where and how much to invest to bring a property to its highest and best use, whether for renovation and resale or renovation for the families' own use.